| At line 4 added 1 line. |
| + ! ''Moderator: Mark Schildhauer'' |
| Line 9 was replaced by line 10 |
| - * Description of current ontologies (Rich) |
| + * Description of current ontologies (Rich) |
| At line 10 added 9 lines. |
| + * Annotate-fest |
| + ** Example GARP (IPCC) [see data and metadata|http://metacat.nceas.ucsb.edu/knb/servlet/metacat?action=read&qformat=knb&docid=dpennington.16.2] |
| + ** Example BioDiversity Dataset [see metadata and data |http://metacat.nceas.ucsb.edu/knb/servlet/metacat?action=read&qformat=knb&docid=sev.106.2] |
| + * GUI Design and Issues |
| + ** Search interfaces |
| + ** Annotation/Semantic registration |
| + ** Simple ontology browsing / selection |
| + ** Domain-aware ontology interaction |
| + ** GrOWL integration into Kepler |
| At line 12 added 1 line. |
| + ** What's missing ... how to get to the terms/phrases of scientists ... how to bridge this gap |
| Removed line 16 |
| - ! Participants |
| Lines 18-24 were replaced by line 28 |
| - * Chad Berkley |
| - * Shawn Bowers |
| - * Serguei Krivov |
| - * Bertram Ludaescher |
| - * Mark Schildhauer |
| - * Rich Williams |
| - * ... |
| + ! Notes |
| At line 25 added 31 lines. |
| + * Mark introduction |
| + ** KR Issues: |
| + *** KR used by SMS, and SMS sits between EcoGrid and Kepler |
| + *** Examine, evaluate, and test a number of existing ontologies in CVS (R. Williams) |
| + **** update on status; evaluate utility; determine where to go from here |
| + *** challenges and approaches in creating and visualizing ontologies |
| + **** growl -- intended audience, utility, demo |
| + **** concept maps -> OWL |
| + *** KR in Kepler (interface issues) |
| + **** ontology-assisted search; semantic annotation drawing from ontology repository, propagating these annotations; KR assisting SMS in EcoGrid for automated data integration (EML and more) |
| + *** How ontologies used in kepler |
| + **** describe actors |
| + |
| + * Rich Williams on Ontologies |
| + ** Some developed, some contain place-holders |
| + ** Looking at MeasurementBase.owl |
| + *** EcoOntThing ... these are items that can have names (hasName) |
| + *** basic terminology: Class (concept), Property (attribute, role, slot), Individual (instance), Value (like a string value) |
| + *** subclasses of eco ont thing ... |
| + **** NamedThing -- those things that have names |
| + **** Composites: composed of parts |
| + ***** Exclusive part-wholes |
| + **** Measurements |
| + ***** Units, Dimensions, DerivedUnits, SIUnits |
| + ***** Observation |
| + ****** item measured, spatial context, temporal context, measurement procedure |
| + ***** experiments, observations, observation collections, observation aggregrates |
| + ** Ecological Concepts |
| + *** Ecological Entities > Abiotic Entities > ... etc. |
| + *** Taxonomic groups |
| + *** Biodiversity, traits, etc. |
| Line 27 was replaced by lines 62-63 |
| - ! Notes |
| + * Serguei Krivov |
| + ** GrOWL demo ... |
| Removed line 29 |
| - * ... |
